Australians who speak out against animal cruelty could soon be labelled "agri-terrorists"

Australians who speak out against animal cruelty could soon be labelled "agri-terrorists" if the Abbott government gets their way.

Agriculture Minister Barnaby Joyce is pushing us to follow America’s cowboy politicians. If he succeeds, people who expose animal cruelty could be punished more harshly than those who actually commit the violence on animals under so-called "ag-gag" laws.

The work of animal cruelty campaigners has already exposed the gruesome live export industry, caught workers pushing sick animals with bulldozers, and won some real changes. Their work is often the only way we know about widespread animal abuse in our food systems.

Big corporate farms love Barnaby Joyce’s proposed law, but it’s a disaster for everyone else. If we can generate enough noise, we can push the government to drop its latest unpopular, corporate-backed policy.

Tell Barnaby Joyce to criminalise cruelty -- not whistleblowing -- and drop plans to gag animal rights campaigners.

Big corporate farming interests want to do everything they can to gag animal cruelty activists. They know that when consumers are reminded of how harshly animals are treated in factory farms, they demand change -- which eats into company profits.

The American ag-gag laws were passed after heavy lobbying by farming industry lobbyists, and now the industry wants to do the same thing here.

Barnaby Joyce’s proposed law is a classic case of "shooting the messenger", rather than actually tackling the problem of abuse in factory farming. In the absence of strong independent checks, campaigners often provide some of the only scrutiny of standards of animal welfare.

We should be passing laws to treat all our farm animals with compassion and respect, not gagging those who draw attention to serious abuse. And if enough of us speak out now, we can push the government to drop this unpopular law.


FirstPrev12(page 2/2)
24 comments

I should have known that this too would have brought childish comments, it disgusts me to think that so many are so heartless !

Thanks for your input Abby

Currently, there's no similar legislation being proposed in Australia, but politicians from New South Wales and Western Australia, have expressed their support for stronger action to be taken against animal activists.

Australian Pork Limited chief executive Andrew Spencer says stronger legal protection is needed to protect farmers from activists.

"I don't really know if 'ag-gag' type laws are the answer, but I do believe that we need stronger protection for the rights of farmers, through trespass laws that are a true deterrent for people to carry out these types of farm raids," Mr Spencer said.

"And the biosecurity threats that some of these raids represent, from people who don't really know what that means, they are enormous."

The pork industry and animal welfare groups have endured a combative relationship in Australia in recent years.

Last year, two pig farmers took out apprehended violence orders against the executive director of Animal Liberation, after activists secretly filmed at their piggeries in the New South Wales town of Young and posted some of the footage on YouTube.

"We've got the situation today where we have vegetarian groups raiding pig farms, misrepresenting what goes on on those pig farms through selective film footage and making ridiculous and defamatory claims about what's going on on those farms, all driven from an agenda that animal agriculture should not exist," Mr Spencer said.

"We think that is completely unfair and that the law needs to be able to deal with that effectively."

abc the land

Pete your message being... let the torture of animals continue? just let the owners of the slaughter places carry on with their disgusting treatment, as long as their business makes a profit, typical  liberal thinking, make a profit at all costs. people should work for less, and expect nothing.

We should have inpectors that go around without notice and also inpector always in the slaughter houses

That is far more sensible idea that people raiding properties and not reporting any perceived mistreatment to the authorities to investigate immediately ..

I agree Pete people have to know what they are doing not just raid places

I put this up in 'Hot Topics' on the 28th June. At that time there were only 6,000 signatures but in one week I see we have 30,000 more, which is great. Glad you ran it through again PlanB. The Abbott government must not get their way in introducing this sinister legislation.

What is sinister in not allowing people just to raid a others property .. Two if you are aware of mis treatment to report it immediately to the authorities not the media...

 

Strip away our freedom, just becoz you get a warm feeling when you see certain animals?

Looks like you would support a police state Robo.

No worries Robi'

I can see some sense in reporting such things directly to the authorities as they are often "ambushed" by media reports when they have no knowledge of the problems reported. I would have a MAJOR problem if this legislation requires reporting to authorities while banning reporting to the media as well. That would be a clear violation of our freedom of speech.

To ban animal activists from revealing animal cruelty by ruling that all information can only be handed into authorities for action and potentially be "shelved" with no further expression allowed could soon be extended to other revelations and whistleblowers in other areas.

By all means make it law that BOTH Governmental Bodies and Media are to be informed at the same time but to restrict freedom of speech or action opens the door to Dictatorship and loss of Democracy.

Children,elderly or disabled or  Animals or any other vulnerable groups can only be protected if freedom exists for exposure.

Looks like the petition is well on the way since I signed to a large number of Australins protesting against the legislation.

How dare anyone try to gag people because they know the disgusting treatment of many animals and humans exists.

I would rather be fined than shut up.

That is not the proposal by barnaby Phyl . It is not to shut anyone up but to avoid the situation we had with Jakarta over live cattle exports . 

Where a film was made and given to channell 2. Months later without the authorities in Indinesia or Ausralia being aware or giving the other side of the story . 

The givt reacted in a panic cost Indonesia  its food supply our farmers their livelihood and the taxpayers millions in compensation ...

Live exports should not be allowed to countries that have no empathy owards animals

When the animals get shipped it is not like us going on a holiday on a first line cruiser - it is unecessary stress and mistreatment.

Julia Gillard gained my respect when she had the courage to do that.

But she didn't ...

The cattle are the food supply for Indonesia same as us ..Ours are trucked to the abattoirs theirs are shipped . The suspension was not about shipping but the perceived treatment at one yard . 

Thanks for bumping the thread and keeping it at the fore :)

So any of you guys that have not yet signed it

Please do so now and get your friends and relatives to help with this worthy cause of stopping this barbaric cruel practice to animals.

 

http://action.sumofus.org/a/animal-activists-gagged/?sub=mtl

It would not surprise me to reach 40000 by the end of the day

If your really concerned about animals in Indonesia get involved with saving their endangered species . My daughter is involved with the orangatuans and sharks . Rather than interfere with a poor peoples food supply . Australia has worked with Indonesia and all cattle are stunned ..

Indonesia is famous for its great biodiversity. It is estimated that as many as 300,000 animal species are inhabit its many ecosystems. This equates to 17% of worldwide fauna species, these across only 1.3% of the world's landmass. With 515 species, Indonesia has more species of mammal than any other nation. There are 1539 bird species and 50% of all the world's fish species can be found in its marine and freshwater systems.

http://www.profauna.org/content/en/indonesian_animal_facts.html

The beautiful Sumatran Tiger is almost extinct due to mass clearing of forests for oil palm cultivation.

The last one I saw was Innes, and now he's gone. Thanks in no small part to the so called animal lovers on this forum that hurled nothing but abuse at the poor chap.

I wish he'd come back.

Yes bring back the tiger

I also wish Ken Innes would come back. Come Back

I love him - thank goodness his wife knows this and it is o.k. as Peter also says it is o.k. lol, not that I agree with everything Ken says but we do not all have to agree on everything as long as we agree to disagree politely. Oh yes Ken can be a bit sarcastic and he knows it, but he loves cats so has to rate highly in my book.   

FirstPrev12(page 2/2)
24 comments



To make a comment, please register or login

Preview your comment