The price of loyalty to your first bank

If you’ve been loyal for life to your first bank, you are probably being ripped off.

padlock money

If you are hopelessly devoted to your bank, you probably won’t have your heart broken – as Olivia Newton-John sang – but you are at risk of being robbed blind.

Studies have shown that loyalty for life to one of the major four banks is burning an $80,000 hole in your pocket.

Comparison site Mozo, a regular advocate of shopping around to find a better rate from a smaller lender, estimated that customers of traditional banks who did not refinance loans wasted a whopping $17 million a year.

The founder of The Money Mentor Way, Nicole Pedersen-McKinnon, worked out three years ago that based on interest rates on credit cards, home and personal loans, a lifetime of sticking with your original bank was costing a customer an average of $82,174 – equivalent to the price tag of a luxury car.

Back then, Ms Pedersen-McKinnon claimed that the Big Four lured their unsuspecting customers early, while they were still at school, with schemes such as banking programs, online games and mobile apps.

And they are still at it. Earlier this month, consumer organisation CHOICE lambasted the beleaguered Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CommBank) for “flogging their products” in schools.

The bank was accused of offering incentives to primary schools that helped sign up students to its Dollarmites program.

Shortly after the airing of its latest dirty linen, CommBank decided to withdraw the ‘kickbacks’ from next year.

“We have heard CHOICE’s concerns about these payments and will engage with the schools, parent and citizens’ associations and consumer groups to introduce a change to the way payments are structured from 1 January 2018 that no longer links the payment to the value of students’ deposits,” the bank said in a statement.

CHOICE linked the payments to schools with subconsciously encouraging students to become complacent about reviewing banking options as adults, which led many to stay and pay higher interest rates than they needed to later in life. 

CHOICE’s chief executive, Alan Kirkland, inferred that the Dollarmites program was disguised as a marketing tool to gain “unfettered access” to “flog their products” in schools.

“Rewarding children for saving with cheap toys easily transitions to rewarding young adults with ‘special’ offers of high-interest personal loans and credit cards,” Mr Kirkland said.

“It is time to take banks out of financial literacy education, and to stop them from paying schools commissions to flog their products.”

Comparison sites encourage all bank customers to review their accounts regularly in case they can get a better deal elsewhere. Some of these sites are,, and

Are you still a customer of the original bank you chose? Have you switched banks? If so, why did you decide to swap?



    To make a comment, please register or login
    20th Oct 2017
    Both my wife and I had a commonwealth account from schooldays (when it was owned by the people)After we were married and started the process of kids and house we were treated like dirt as it was now privatised.I have never known a bank to lose so many of it.s original customers through mistreatment and still insist on how it is a caring bank.
    20th Oct 2017
    CBA share price $79 last time I checked
    20th Oct 2017
    Yes good price especially if you purchased them at their IPO price which I think was $5.60 Raphael no doubt you have some put away for that rainy day.

    20th Oct 2017
    ALL banks rob you blind. Loyalty has nothing to do with it.
    20th Oct 2017
    They are there to make a profit for there shareholders bugger the customer if you are stupid enough to stay at a bank and get robbed blind well so be it.
    20th Oct 2017
    poly wants a cracker, love to see for once a possitive reaction of you for the question asked
    21st Oct 2017
    Roby, do you suggest stuffing cash in your mattress?

    heemskerk, you need to learn what the word polymath means - and to spell. If you're alluding to parrots, the correct expression is "Polly wants a cracker". And the other word to be spelt correctly in your brief sentence is "positive".

    You May Like