Australia Institute supports cap on tax advice deductions

Font Size:

Bill Shorten’s Budget reply speech earlier this month outlined a plan to limit the tax deductions available for the cost of managing tax affairs to $3000. New analysis of tax data shows this change would affect very few Australians.

Shorten said that one of the biggest deductions (on average around $1 million) claimed by millionaires who paid no tax was to their accountants.

“These individuals are not just counting cards in the casino – they are bringing their own dealer and their own deck. Loopholes for millionaires, means middle Australia pays more,” he said.

“That’s why a Labor Government will cap the amount individuals can deduct for the management of their tax affairs at $3000.”

The Australia Institute has researched the data and found that the change would have no impact on most Australians.

The majority of Australians make no claim for managing their tax affairs, and even among those in the top three per cent of income earners, most claims do not exceed the $3000 mark.

However, the policy does stand to net gains for the government due to the size of the claims of aggressive tax minimisers, some of whom claim over $1 million in deductions for tax advice annually.

Those on over $1 million dollar incomes deduct an average of $12,657 for the management of their tax affairs.

“A $3000 dollar cap will go unnoticed by the vast majority of Australian taxpayers,” senior economist at The Australia Institute, Matt Grudnoff said.

“One of the most remarkable figures we uncovered was the average deduction for those who earn over $1 million dollars and don’t pay any income tax. They spent, on average, over $1 million dollars on tax advice in a year.

“This loophole is legal, but when it’s being exploited in such an excessive way it probably doesn’t pass the pub test for most taxpayers,” Grudnoff said.

One of the interesting findings from The Australia Institute’s research is that nine out of the top 10 electorates with the highest cost for managing their tax affairs are Liberal strongholds, with the ALP-held Melbourne Ports the only exception.

Read The Australia Institute report.

Opinion: Closing obvious tax-dodging loophole a no-brainer

Government attempts to make Australia’s highest income earners pay their fair share of tax are always a bit like a game of whack-a-mole. As soon as one loophole is closed, accountants are able to find another one that has opened up and the chase seems to go on forever.

However, Labor’s latest policy does seem like a very sensible way of addressing the issue, taking away one of the easiest ways hide money from the ATO, while having zero impact on middle and low-income households.

Any time tax figures highlight the incredibly low tax paid by the country’s highest earners, Australians are rightly furious, especially when the Government is giving big business a $65 million tax cut.

The change seems logical. Not only will it force the very highest income earners to pay more of the tax that they owe, it will raise $1.8 billion over the next decade according to Shadow Treasurer Chris Bowen.

Unfortunately, the Liberal Party doesn’t seem to have much interest in this proposal, and once you look at the electorate breakdown of those most affected it is easy to see why. Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull’s Wentworth electorate has the second-highest average cost of managing tax affairs in the country, behind Assistant Treasurer Kelly O’Dwyer’s seat in Higgins.

What do you think? Should there be a cap on the deductions available for managing your tax affairs? Do you employ a tax agent or do your taxes yourself?


Is the Australian Tax Office stalking your Facebook posts?

Government departments, such as the ATO, are looking at your social media posts.

Age Pension – is my pension super taxed?

Ken is confused about how his Age Pension and income stream are taxed.

Will you be in the ATO's sights at tax time?

If you own a rental property, you'll be in the ATO's crosshairs come tax time.

Written by Ben


Sign-up to the YourLifeChoices Enewsletter

continue reading

Age Pension

Centrelink Q&A: Is it possible to get two pensions?

Doug wonders if it is legal to claim two pensions while living overseas. Q. DougIs it possible to get two...


Older Australians resist downsizing, preferring home to a move

The housing boom is slowing the rate at which Australians are downsizing, with many older homeowners preferring to stay in...

Brain health

Loss of pleasure and happiness linked to dementia

Those living with a type of dementia that affects younger people can't feel as happy as they did before developing the...


Can coffee cure a headache? Or is it the culprit?

If you do enough research on coffee, specifically caffeine, you could start to believe it’s a wonder drug. Health professionals...


Pumpkin, Leek and Spinach Quiche

Looking for a no-fuss quiche recipe? Today’s Pumpkin, Leek and Spinach Quiche can be made with no pastry, which makes...


Pondering love letter etiquette

The French have a lovely name for a love letter - a billet doux. The translation literally means sweet letter...


Long-lasting beauty treatments to do at home

If this past year has shown us anything, it's that home pampering should not be overlooked. Going to a salon...

Brain health

Medical focus must extend to pre-clinical dementia

Ivan Koychev, University of Oxford 'One more question', is now a regular parting shot from the son or daughter of...