Older drivers are overconfident

Can we trust older drivers to decide when to hand in their licences?

While Newcastle University in the UK is developing systems to help keep older drivers on the road, the Queensland University of Technology (QUT) is canning older drivers.

QUT has conducted a study into the driving ability versus driving confidence of 98 men and women between 65 and 85 years of age. The study showed that people were not as good at driving as they thought they were, and the older a driver was, the more confident but less able they were.

They were not, however, actually tested on their driving. The participants’ ability was instead marked using a hazard perception test. This is a computerised driving simulator, where the participant has to see and react to hazards on the road, such as pedestrians and braking vehicles.

I took a hazard perception test myself a few years ago, and it was one of the most difficult tests I’ve ever done. Not because the test was hard, but because the technology was so poor. The graphics were pixelated, which made seeing anything very difficult, and the computer was so slow that by the time the computer had registered my request to start braking, I had already run over four people.

Now, it’s possible the hazard perception test the participants in this study took was different, or of a better quality, than the standard test given in Victoria. But even if the test was of the highest quality, statistically speaking the older the person taking the test, the less likely they are to be familiar with computers. This in itself is likely to skew the results.

The study concluded that the older a driver is, the less able they are to self-assess whether or not they should be driving. Why is it that in Australia we are asking our older drivers to play a computer game, and then condemning them, whereas in the UK they are using technology to work towards keeping older drivers on the road? Is it sheer laziness on our part? Or are we just less forward-thinking?

More information
To find out how the UK’s ‘DriveLAB’ is keeping older drivers on the road, read the YOURLifeChoices news article Too old to drive.

How should we regulate older drivers in Australia?
Older drivers should decide when to stop driving
There should be an arbitrary cut-off age
Older drivers should sit a yearly driving test
 



Have your say
What do you think? Can we trust older drivers to decide when to hand in their licences? Or should there be an arbitrary cut-off age for drivers? And should we be doing more as a country to keep our older drivers independent and mobile?





    COMMENTS

    To make a comment, please register or login
    gustacian
    2nd May 2012
    10:04pm
    As the majority of people reading this would be classified as older drivers it is safe to assume we would be slightly biased. Most of us believe we are good drivers and will remain good drivers until we decide to give up driving of our own volition. However, ask a younger driver and they may well have a different opinion. Tricky subject, this.
    diogenes
    4th May 2012
    11:06am
    I am 67 years of age and know that I am a competent and not over-confident driver. This was confirmed a few months ago when I did my driving test in the Fire Engine, passed, and am now qualified to drive the monster to emergencies. So much for generalising about "older" drivers. Three cheers and more to the UK for their attitude


    Join YOURLifeChoices, it’s free

    • Receive our daily enewsletter
    • Enter competitions
    • Comment on articles