SMSF performance falls short of APRA-regulated funds

Font Size:

A sum of $200,000 is often what is quoted as being enough to justify owning an SMSF but the reality is that it should be 10 times that amount to be truly effective.

Analysis of data from the Australian Tax Office (ATO) by Industry Super Australia economists has discovered that the average net return for an SMSF in 2015 was only 6.2 per cent. When compared to retail and industry funds of similar balances, which had returns of 7.8 per cent and 9.7 per cent respectively, the reality of an SMSF isn’t so rosy.

And the range of returns on SMSF varies greatly depending on the balance of its assets – minus 16.9 per cent for funds with balances of less than $50,000 to 7.7 per cent for funds with balances of $2 million.

Industry Super’s chief economist Stephen Anthony said the findings should confirm once and for all the value of an SMSF. “A self-managed super fund with less than $2 million in assets is unviable as a retirement savings vehicle.

“The best performing SMSFs will have a diverse portfolio of assets is unviable as a retirement savings vehicle.”

Yet, SMSFs remain popular, with a spike in ownership amongst younger members aged 35 to 44. SMSF ownership increased by 5.5 per cent in 2015.

Citing the findings of a 2016 CIFR Working Paper, which linked SMSF popularity to low financial literacy, high confidence and links to financial and tax professions, Mr Anthony said, “We share the view that SMSF sector growth is being driven by sales efforts. It’s important that consumers look at the returns and fully understand what they’re signing up to.”

Read more at Industry Super Australia


Super may have started out slow, but robust returns are predicted

Want to know how well super has performed so far this year?

How much is needed for an SMSF?

Keith is questioning whether he has sufficient funds to start an SMSF.

SuperRatings releases its top 10 superannuation funds

SuperRatings releases its report on the top ten performing funds for 2016.

Written by Debbie McTaggart


Sign-up to the YourLifeChoices Enewsletter

continue reading


Australians give big thumbs down to the public service

Only 27 per cent of Australians believe the public service acts in the public interest and only 22 per cent...

Brain health

Normal tension glaucoma linked to cognitive impairment

Australian researchers say they have established a link between the eye condition glaucoma and cognitive impairment, the state that often...


Old wives' tales put to the test

Alice Shaw-Beckett, from cleaning company Cleanipedia, dissects 13 old wives' tales related to cleaning and pest control to discover whether...

Travel & Motoring

Consider this when deciding on a roadside assist deal

A reader raised an interesting point that I hadn’t considered before. When she bought her new car, it included -...

Technology News

Which portable heater is best?

As the famous Stark motto from Game of Thrones states, 'Winter is Coming' and that means putting the flannelette sheets...


What works, what won't, if you get your phone wet

Ritesh Chugh, CQUniversity Australia If you've ever got your phone wet in the rain, dropped it in water or spilt...


Are natural alternatives better than refined sugar?

Eating sugar shouldn't be demonised and tucking into a bar of chocolate after a stressful day is nothing to punish...

Health news

What your body may be trying to tell you

One of the unforeseen outcomes of a pandemic is that fewer people are going to the doctor to get unusual...