You wouldn’t hit a dog, so why kill one in a video game?

Font Size:

Simon Coghlan, University of Melbourne and Lucy Sparrow, University of Melbourne

Violence against animals in video games is ubiquitous. Players can kill or torture animals in various popular games, including Minecraft and Grand Theft Auto V. The rise of this (increasingly realistic) trend in games, along with people’s tendency to go along with it, raises important questions.

Violence against humans in video games has long been contentious – underpinned by the never-ending debate over whether on-screen violence begets the real thing. But violence against animals in video games has attracted considerably less attention.

In a recently published paper, we argue there is good reason to think violence against animals in video games is problematic – perhaps even more so than in-game violence against humans. We think game violence against animals is more likely to promote disrespect for their living counterparts.

The jury is out
In 2005, Australia banned a first-person shooter game called Postal 2, in which players could mutilate and desecrate (virtual) human bodies. Australia has controversially banned several games available in other countries because of depictions of violence and other potentially objectionable themes.

Players evidently have varying views on harming virtual animals. Some express concern or remorse – one gamer wrote on a forum:

It’s weird how bad I feel about killing animals in the game … I will actively try and shoot guys off horses instead of just shooting the horses.

People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) – itself a somewhat troubled organisation – has criticised games it says “promote hurting and killing” animals. Examples include whale hunting in Assassin’s Creed, and fishing and catching bugs in Animal Crossing: New Horizons.

Other players have no such qualms, however, with one writing:

I kill humans in games all the time. Why would I care about animals?

Many share this view. Video game ‘amoralists’ say abusing animals (or humans) in video games can’t be wrong, as the ‘victims’ are virtual and no living being is hurt.

It’s not clear exactly why players feel so differently about in-game violence. Attitudes towards in-game violence may be shaped by personal views, social mores, gaming culture and also the amount someone plays violent games.

If video games can promote particular ethical messages, could certain games encourage disrespect for living things?

A sniper focuses on a chicken in a video game. First-person shooters, such as Call of Duty, have been around for more than 45 years now. They’re some of the most popular video games today. jit/Flickr, CC BY-NC-SA

A moral dilemma in plain sight
Social scientists have long debated whether violent video games cause antisocial attitudes towards other people. Some think they might, but conclusive evidence for a causal link is lacking. The moral issue of violence against animals in video games has received much less philosophical attention.

Both animals and humans are often portrayed as objects to kill and harm for fun in gaming. However, animals are presented in even more disposable ways. They are often mere tools for players to kill to complete quests, or to gain materials and trophies.

This is true even for games in which players are encouraged to reflect morally on their in-game actions. In Dragon Age: Inquisition, the game’s characters will approve or disapprove of a wide variety of player actions. But harming non-aggressive wild animals is not one of the things that prompts a moral reaction.

While societal respect for animals is growing (albeit slowly), animals today are routinely treated very badly. We confine them to factory farms, put them on live export ships where many suffer (and even die) and ‘humanely’ kill unwanted companion animals.

Many of us ignore these realities. Morally speaking, animals are relatively invisible to society – whereas other humans generally are not. In this context, depicting animals as disposable commodities in video games could reinforce disrespect towards them, at least for many players.

Some games may help normalise the mistreatment and moral invisibility of animals.

Examining our prejudices
So if video games can, in fact, reinforce disrespect for animals, does this mean we should ban or boycott them? We don’t advocate that. However, it would be useful for scientists to investigate whether video games do help or hinder social respect for animals.

Game designers may also consider depicting animals in ways that encourage (or at least don’t inadvertently discourage) respecting them. Some already do this. In Red Dead Redemption, killing your horse leads to the same loss of ‘honour’ points as killing an innocent person.

Character on his horse in Red Dead Redemption 2. In the Red Dead game series, ‘honour’ is a system that measures the social acceptability of the main character in his world. Specific in-game actions are considered honourable or dishonourable. ekkun/Flickr, CC BY-NC

Finally, players themselves could choose to become more aware of how animals are portrayed in the various games they spend hours of their lives absorbed in.

Given the enormous popularity and ongoing transformation of video games, there is an opportunity here for all of us to reassess our often unjust treatment of animals.

Simon Coghlan, Senior Research Fellow in Digital Ethics, Centre for AI and Digital Ethics, School of Computing and Information Systems, University of Melbourne and Lucy Sparrow, PhD Candidate in Human-Computer Interaction, University of Melbourne

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons licence. Read the original article.

Do you think that online violence begets the real thing?

If you enjoy our content, don’t keep it to yourself. Share our free eNews with your friends and encourage them to sign up.

Join YourLifeChoices today
and get this free eBook!

Join
By joining YourLifeChoices you consent that you have read and agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

RELATED LINKS

Computer games heal the world

Online gaming may be more effective at treating clinical depression than pharmaceuticals

Which video games are best for your brain?

Are there video games that can keep your mind healthy?

Here’s why board games are booming

We explain the attraction of board games and the emerging trends in the new releases.

Written by The Conversation

4 Comments

Total Comments: 4
  1. 0
    0

    Who knows what kind of behaviour these senseless games lead to.

  2. 0
    0

    Its not only these senseless games.
    When they make TV shows that have convicted drug runners go on to do these reality shows are only giving our impressionable young people the ok to be drug runners one minute and then get paid to be in the public eye.
    Ban these brainless TV shows as well, who cares if a lot of Bogans sit and watch TV while being recorded as observers and pay them to make stupid comments about the shows they are watching. All scripted and badly at that.
    The sexist and low moral shows like Big brother and castaway are a joke and an insult to intelligent people. There is no entertainment value except for the morally deficient and low intelligent bogans.
    If these are allowed to continue to be broadcast it will corrupt the morals of the kids. we know parents should be restricting what their kids watch, but this is no incentive to those slack parents who let their offspring watch anything that will keep the kids quiet while they drink their beer or visit the pokies.
    They also don’t care if the kids play these dumb games.
    Parents are responsible for their kids until 18 years of age, you never hear about parents being charged if their little darling break the law, drug drive, graffiti, kill someone while robbing for drugs etc.
    Fine the parents and they soon will know where their delinquent kids are.

  3. 0
    0

    Strategy video games, in particular, have shown promise in improving brain function among older adults and may provide protection against dementia and Alzheimer’s disease. Use this link to learn more about video games and how to master this skill in order to make some good cash on your hobby.

  4. 0
    0

    I am sure that you will not resist making extra money, especially if you can do it by spending time with your favorite video game on the site https://csgobettings.com/coinflip/ as this is where you will find the top betting platforms. Don’t miss your chance.


FACEBOOK COMMENTS



SPONSORED LINKS

continue reading

Technology News

Would you let AI choose your partner?

David Tuffley, Griffith University It could be argued that artificial intelligence (AI) is already the indispensable tool of the 21st...

Food and Recipes

How to spice up hummus

Few things are as universally loved as hummus. A blend of chickpeas, lemon, tahini, garlic, olive oil and cumin, whizzed...

COVID-19

Intensive care during COVID like a 'delirium factory', study finds

An international study of COVID-19 treatments has found patients admitted to intensive care early in the pandemic were treated by...

Fitness

The surprising health and fitness benefits of golf

Recently, many have had to rely on walking or virtual fitness classes to keep going with their favourite sports and...

Finance

Five smart moves for empty nesters

So, the kids have moved out, your home is finally yours again and you have ascended to the rank of...

Lifestyle

Why you turn down the radio when you're trying to park your car?

When you're looking for a destination, you might need to cut down the volume. Shutterstock Simon Lilburn, University of Melbourne...

Technology

Why we can expect smarter healthcare in 2021 and other tech trends

With last year dominated by the COVID-19 pandemic and much the same expected for 2021, it is unsurprising that healthcare...

Mental Health

Drug trial offers rare hope on Alzheimer's disease

There is finally a glimmer of hope in the fight against Alzheimer's, the most common form of dementia, which affects...

LOADING MORE ARTICLE...