Reports 'demonic' robo-debt algorithms are now targeting pensioners

Font Size:

Independent MP Andrew Wilkie raised concerns on Monday that pensioners are becoming the latest target of Centrelink’s much-maligned data-matching system.

Last month, the federal government agreed to pay $112 million in compensation to approximately 400,000 individual group members in a class action settlement, after they were wrongly accused of owing Centrelink money.

Robo-debt was a system where Centrelink used a computer in an effort to calculate welfare overpayments to establish that a debt was owed.

That system used data from the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) and averaged income data across either part or all of the fortnights in which recipients received payments. It treated those averaged amounts as actual earnings and often ignored what the recipient actually earned at the time, causing many false debts to be raised.

Mr Wilkie told parliament that pensioners had contacted his office, claiming that a similar automated Centrelink system was now contacting them.

“Centrelink’s automated data-matching system is now terrorising pensioners, this time with demonic algorithms bombarding the elderly with reams of threatening and confusing correspondence,” Mr Wilkie said.

“Increasingly, I am hearing from constituents hit with automation of income stream system reviews.

“For instance, an 89-year-old woman who received a letter ordering her online to provide the government information lest her pension be cut off. And another, who indeed did have her payment cancelled due to an error that would have been obvious to the human eye.”

Mr Wilkie urged the government to learn from the robo-debt scandal and order a halt “to this latest robo-monster”.

Prime Minister Scott Morrison denied that there was anything wrong with the system and asked pensioners to follow the instructions and provide the information they were being asked to supply.

“Services Australia requires information about income streams held by payment recipients to calculate their payment entitlements under the social security income and assets test,” Mr Morrison said. “That is their job.”

Mr Morrison said that the letter to pensioners contained either a number to call or an opportunity to go online.

“I would simply ask people … if they have received such a letter … that they would simply contact that number, or go online as the letter suggests, and provide the information that they have been asked for and that should lead to the ready resolution of those issues,” Mr Morrison said.

Watch the exchange between Mr Wilkie and Mr Morrison here:

In related robo-debt news, critics of the system fear Centrelink’s new debt collectors have failed to learn from the failures of the old system, with tender documents revealing that new collection agencies must continuously compete to beat financial target for recovering money from customers.

Australian Unemployed Workers Union spokeswoman Kristin O’Connell told the ABC tat she was surprised that the department was going to outsource the work.

“As the government’s own documents acknowledge, this outsourcing model means debt collectors have incentives that can result in ‘unintended and perverse’ behaviour to meet targets and trigger fees,” Ms O’Connell said.

Have you received a letter from Centrelink asking you to provide information or lose you pension? Are you worried you may be wrongly targeted by Centrelink’s data-matching system?

If you enjoy our content, don’t keep it to yourself. Share our free eNews with your friends and encourage them to sign up.


Calls for robo-debt royal commission as class action is settled

Government settles class action against robo-debt for $1.2 billion.

December Centrelink changes to affect half a million

New reporting changes due to start on 7 December will save the government $2.1 billion.

How to check your eligibility for the $250 economic support payment

The first round of extra government payments announced in the budget should arrive soon.

Written by Ben


Sign-up to the YourLifeChoices Enewsletter

continue reading


Ambulance costs around Australia

There should be no hesitation when you have to call an ambulance in an emergency situation, but some people rushed...


Four tell-tale signs that you may have a blood clot

A blood clot is a clump of cells and protein in your blood. Blood clots form to slow down bleeding...

Finance News

How much you can save on electricity in your home state

As we prepare to head into the colder winter months, there is good news for those worried about heating costs...


What is thrombocytopenia, and why did it stop the AstraZeneca jab?

Anthony Zulli, Victoria University; Maja Husaric, Victoria University; Maximilian de Courten, Victoria University, and Vasso Apostolopoulos, Victoria University Australia's medical...


Ways to manage death anxiety

Winston Churchill once said: "Any man who says he is not afraid of death is a liar." But while it's...

Food and Recipes

Rick Stein's Autumn Vegie Soup

"One of the rather pathetic realities of the fact that so many of the restaurants in France are disappointing these...


Australians give big thumbs down to the public service

Only 27 per cent of Australians believe the public service acts in the public interest and only 22 per cent...

Brain health

Normal tension glaucoma linked to cognitive impairment

Australian researchers say they have established a link between the eye condition glaucoma and cognitive impairment, the state that often...