Tax raid in store on super earnings?

Font Size:

Worthless interest rates on cash in the bank, plummeting superannuation balances and dividend catastrophes on many stocks that were previously gold plated – that’s the nightmare for many retirees and pre-retirees. Is there more bad news in store? Perhaps.

While many analysts are highlighting the often baffling, secretive and excessive fees charged by some superannuation funds, Rice Warner founder and executive director Michael Rice points out another area that he says the federal government may harness to repay the massive debt created by COVID-19.

Superannuation will no longer be as sacred as it was in the past, he says in a report, referring to the tax advantages delivered by the current super system and regularly criticised by economists such as The Australia Institute’s Matt Grudnoff as concessions that help the rich get richer and do nothing to dent the number of older Australians living in poverty.

“When it comes to super tax concessions and excess franking credits, we’re handing out the most to those who already have the most,” he told YourLifeChoices. “Super tax concessions are worth $41 billion per year. The richest 20 per cent of retirees, who are not on an Age Pension or part pension, get 60 per cent of super tax concessions. The bottom half, those most likely to need help in retirement, get just 11 per cent of super tax concessions.”

Mr Warner says all Australians will need to pay their share of taxes to help repay “our bloated national debt” but that superannuation is a “relatively soft target” and that associated tax concessions are likely to be reviewed by the government.

He warns that while our ‘elephantine’ system works well in aggregate, accumulation and pension earnings could be taxed at the same rate to raise revenue, predicting that would increase taxes from the superannuation funds collectively by “close to 50 per cent” as well as simplifying the system by removing the need for a pension transfer balance. Super earnings incur a 15 per cent tax while earnings in the pension phase are tax free

“Before the government does make a tax grab, it should look at the existing inequities in the system,” he says. “The top 100 SMSFs collectively hold about $8.7 billion. Many appear to be run as businesses – according to the ATO (Australian Tax Office), one even has a loan of $168 million against property holdings.

“Taxing the wealthy first always makes good political sense.”

Mr Warner says superannuation should pay its share of the burden, but adds: “Let’s hope anychanges are well targeted, don’t make the system even more complicated, and still allow the system to do its job, which is to provide better retirement outcomes.”

Mercer’s David Knox says there are two ways the government could tackle the debt – through increased taxation of super and reduced benefits. He predicts the federal government will opt for “a bit of both” in respect of the retirement system and older people, generally.

The retirement specialist says the government may increase the tax on the investment income for pensioners and that it may make the Age Pension harder to get.

“We must also realise that investment returns are likely to be lower in the future, compared to recent years,” he says in Investment Magazine.

“Hence, in my view, for all these reasons we need to encourage greater self-sufficiency in retirement, rather than less. However, we also need to make the total system much simpler.”

The government’s Retirement Income Review is set to report on 24 July.

What is your view on increased taxation on super pension earnings?

If you enjoy our content, don’t keep it to yourself. Share our free eNews with your friends and encourage them to sign up.


How the online shopping boom is hurting your super

Property returns to superannuation funds are predicted to decline.

Experts analyse expected super earnings

Rice Warner reveals what to expect in superannuation earnings over the next 10 years.

Super switch cap will hurt us all

Comment: Government changes introduced in 2017 will eventually mean all of us will be taxed more

Written by Janelle Ward


Sign-up to the YourLifeChoices Enewsletter

continue reading


Podcast: Banishing winter blues with cold water companionship

COVID lockdowns can do funny things to people, but last year Melburnian Belle Galloway decided to do something she had...


Soothe your soul with these stunning images of Japan's cherry blossoms

It's sakura season, the perfect opportunity for locals to indulge in hanami, the traditional Japanese custom of 'flower viewing'. On...


Discover New Zealand's best winter attractions

To mark the start of the trans-Tasman bubble, here are some of the best things to do in New Zealand...


Check your passport's expiry date before booking

International travel seems to be slowly but surely returning. With the trans-Tasman bubble and talks of another bubble opening with...


Tips for getting a good night's sleep on holiday

Travel can seriously mess with our sleep. The jet lag that disrupts our body clocks may be the most obvious...


Tasmania's top spots for shopping and markets

The Margate Train offers shopping with a difference at Margate, southern Tasmania. Margate is 20 minutes south of Hobart (19km)...


What will it take for travel to get restarted again?

Maraid is encouraged by the travel bubble with New Zealand opening up and wonders what needs to happen before we...


The unbelievable software flaw that led to a major flight incident

When it comes to flight engineering, you would hope that every possibility has been factored in to perfection, but a...