CHOICE tells which Christmas pudding gets its gold star

Font Size:

Looking for the perfect Christmas pudding? One that will set tastebuds a’tingling and mouths a’watering? How about one that will add a little glitter to your Christmas table?

Well, according to CHOICE, the pudding to place on your table this year is a newcomer to (what this writer learnt was) the competitive field of festive desserts.

For years, the Coles Finest Luxury Pudding has been the gold standard (pardon the pun, you’ll get it in a minute) for splashy sweets. While the pudding alone – infused with French brandy and topped with cherries and Valencian oranges – is glitzy enough, the satchel of sugared gold glitter you sprinkle over the pudding once it’s heated and ready to serve sends it over the top. A pretentious pud, one might say.

But the Coles Finest Luxury Pudding has been knocked off its perch this year by Aldi’s Luxury Golden Champagne Pudding, no less flamboyant and all the more delicious.

The Aldi entrant is soaked in its own budget yet award-winning Veuve Monsigny Brut Champagne, also topped with cherries, and also with gold glitter for that touch of magic.

coles and aldi christmas puddings

Aldi was crowned by CHOICE as the premier pudding for 2019. CHOICE blind tasted and rated 13 Christmas puddings to find the perfect pud.

Puddings under the microscope ranged from high end to budget and were judged on:

  • shape
  • weight
  • balance of spice, fruit and alcohol flavours
  • whether there was an even distribution of good-quality fruit ingredients
  • whether they held their shape or collapsed when cut (because no one wants an unidentified mess on the table once the first person takes their slice).

CHOICE’s expert score consisted of appearance/quality of finish (25 per cent), flavour and aroma (40 per cent), texture/baked quality (20 per cent) and mixture quality (15 per cent).

The Aldi pudding came out on top, scoring 89 per cent, with the Coles pud scoring 72 per cent.

“The Aldi pud is a bit of glitz, a bit of fun. It’s a nice, rich, fruit pudding without being sticky and it’s not overly sweet, which I found the Coles one to be,” said CHOICE tester and food consultant Brigid Treloar.  

“It’s great value considering the generous fruit topping and it looks a bit special on the table – an easy Christmas centrepiece at a time when things can get quite busy and expensive, and all you have to do is whack it in the microwave to heat it up.”

CHOICE notes: “Although it’s arguable that there’s nothing better than a homemade Christmas pudding (you can’t beat that dose of love and attention that goes into baking your own, after all), our experts noted that buying all the ingredients yourself, including the alcohol if that’s your cup of tea, can be quite expensive. Not to mention the time required to bake and ‘feed’ your pud with booze in the weeks leading up to Christmas to keep it moist and flavourful.” 

CHOICE expert and CWA judge Alison Mutton said the answer for a time-starved host could be the Aldi option

“If you don’t have time to do a complicated Christmas dessert, this is a good option. I ate absolutely everything that was on my plate,” she said.

What’s your idea of the perfect pudding? Do you make your own? Do you even like Christmas pudding? Which festive dessert do you prefer?

If you enjoy our content, don’t keep it to yourself. Share our free eNews with your friends and encourage them to sign up.

Join YourLifeChoices today
and get this free eBook!

By joining YourLifeChoices you consent that you have read and agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy


Christmas with The Katering Show

The Katering Show Christmas is an irreverent look at how best to deal with the silly se

Last-minute Christmas Pudding

It's quick and easy and your guests will never know they caught you unawares..

Christmas Gingerbread Biscuits

This is a surefire gingerbread recipe that everyone will love.

Written by Leon Della Bosca

Leon Della Bosca is a voracious reader who loves words. You'll often find him spending time in galleries, writing, designing, painting, drawing, or photographing and documenting street art. He has a publishing and graphic design background and loves movies and music, but then, who doesn’t?



Total Comments: 5
  1. 0

    I’ve never heard of a baked Xmas pudding?
    Mine (made in early October) was boiled in a calico cloth for about 6 hours then will be boiled again for another 3 hours on Xmas morning. Until then it hangs in a dark airy space in my pantry.

  2. 0

    Make your own Xmas pudding and gift it to family.

  3. 0

    yes Aldi’s are the best, now I have moved to Tasmania cant get it, come on Aldi, open up here we are still Australia.

  4. 0

    Will still stick to the Coles Luxury one, which we liked last year- if I do not find another anywhere else., will not touch anything from ALDI.
    However I will make my own Mince Pies – as the shop we have tried so far have all had pastry which was too think and crusty – not good for elderly teeth!

  5. 0

    delicious indeed



continue reading


Jenny Eclair: 'Middle-aged women aren't invisible, they are just ignor

"I've had a lapse back into the menopause today," Jenny Eclair declares at the start of our interview. "I had...

Aged Care

Is your loved one in aged care during the pandemic? Here are seven ideas to make things easier if lockdown strikes again

Many families have faced the stress of having a loved one in aged care during this anxious time of COVID-19....

Health & Ageing

How The Midlife Method author keeps her health on track

In The Midlife Method, food and lifestyle writer Sam Rice explores why it is so much harder to lose weight...


How to … tell if you're oversleeping and what to do

An adult needs between seven-and-a-half to nine hours of sleep each night. If you're consistently sleeping for longer than this...


Hand in hand at London Zoo with a simian friend

YourLifeChoices' 91-year-old columnist Peter Leith recalls an encounter of the simian kind during a visit to London Zoo back in...


Retirement Made Simple

In this interview with podcast host John Deeks, the 80-year-old offers pearls of wisdom on all matters retirement: the sea...


The last blockbuster had an end of summer sleepover

Several months ago, the last Blockbuster store on Earth temporarily rebranded - as an extremely nostalgic Airbnb. A few lucky...


Best day trips from Melbourne

We've got more reasons than ever to embrace the adventures we can find in our own backyard and, luckily, Victoria...