Top-performing funds named, but PC thinks they could do better

Top super funds announced, but the Productivity Commission thinks they could do better.

Top-performing funds named, but PC thinks they could do better

The annual winners of Rainmaker Information’s SelectingSuper Awards have been announced, with a new fund taking out top honours.

The awards recognise the best super funds in Australia, as well as the top-performing pension funds and retirement products.

The list of winners comes with a recommendation from Rainmaker that Australians need to choose their fund wisely.

“If they do so, members can be confident they will retire comfortably,” said Rainmaker research director Alex Dunnin.

“But if they choose poorly, they could be missing out on tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in potential retirement savings,” he warned.

This year’s SelectingSuper Fund of the Year has been awarded to Hostplus, which took out five of the top awards and was last named fund of the year in 2014.

Earlier this year, Rainmaker’s rival, Chant West, also nominated a Hostplus fund as the best performer. Respected comparison site, SuperRatings, however, nominated UniSuper as its fund of the year last month.

Rainmaker said Hostplus had regularly been a high achiever in SelectingSuper’s monthly performance tables across both the MySuper and personal product categories, generating exceptional returns for their 1 million plus members.

AvSuper took out the Members’ Choice Award for the second year running, which is given d to the fund that is best able to engage members through a voting process, signifying the fund’s ability to engage a community around superannuation.

The list of the 2018 SelectingSuper Awards include:

Fund of the Year

Best in Show – MySuper Product

Best in Show - MySuper LifeStage Product
Sunsuper for Life Business

Best Personal Choice Product
AustralianSuper Personal Plan

Best Retirement Product
CareSuper Pension

Best Performance – Australian Equities
Catholic Super

Best Performance - International Equities
Vision Super Saver

Best Performance – Fixed Interest

Best Performance – Property
Prime Super

Best Asset Consultant
JANA Investment Advisers

Best Value Insurance in Super
IAG & NRMA Superannuation Plan & MLC Limited

Best Millennial Super Product

Best MySuper Performance – Risk Weighted

Best Long-term Performance

Investment Leadership Award

Members' Choice Award

Industry Service Award
Lawrie Cox

“Winners are chosen based on quantitative and qualitative research using Rainmaker Information's extensive database of research, long-term profiling of the superannuation industry and an eye toward current trends in the super industry,” Mr Dunnin said.

“Super funds continue to surprise on the upside, achieving average returns of more than nine per cent in 2017-18.

“At the same time these funds are working hard to lower fees and insurance premium costs while innovating with more responsive products, which highlights how well superannuation funds in Australia are doing their job.

“Australia’s best super funds routinely earn more than double what the worst performers, deliver so members should check at least once a year whether their fund is still the right one for them.

“Not all funds are the same. It’s also no surprise the top funds in Australia have an enviable track record in adopting new technology, lowering fees, and proactively working with their members’ industries and communities,” he said.

Mr Dunnin is right in saying that not all funds are the same, with analysis from the Productivity Commission (PC) suggesting that if the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) were to force a merger of top performing funds with poor performing funds, fund members would save around $1.8 billion each year.

As reported in The Australian, Analysis of the $2.7 trillion super system from the Productivity Commission revealed that average retirement savings would be $22,000 higher across the board if high-cost funds merged with low-cost funds.

The findings, released on the weekend, come ahead of the royal commission grilling APRA over its poor performance in policing the super industry.


Is your super fund an award winner? Are you happy with your fund? Would you switch to one of these funds? Would you be happy to receive an extra $22,000 under the Productivity Commission’s suggestion?

How does your super affect your overall retirement income? The RetirePlanner™ tool has all the information you need.



    To make a comment, please register or login
    26th Nov 2018
    Don't tell me, Industry Funds romped in? How strange.
    Maybe all management in these funds need to be sacked and Rose Bay professionals put in their place.
    Old Geezer
    26th Nov 2018
    Well Mick there is one there that is mentioned quite a few times that I would not touch with a barge pole.
    26th Nov 2018
    My money has been invested in a Industry Fund for a very long time and has always done much better than a Retail Fund.Mick I would like to see the Old Fibber lifting his barge pole.
    Old Geezer
    26th Nov 2018
    I would not invest my super in either an industry or retail fund.
    26th Nov 2018
    Good call floss. From the mouths of babes........chuckle.
    Gee Whiz
    26th Nov 2018
    Reading the above "Best industry funds" is a bit like understanding out how Atomic physics works.

    Surely there must be a better way of publishing the best of all the funds instead of putting up twenty funds and throwing a dart to select the best one.

    Number them one, two, three in rank of best overall performance.

    26th Nov 2018
    My retail fund has given me 14% returns in the last 5 years. Better than all of the above
    Karl Marx
    26th Nov 2018
    What fund is that Lothario. If you don't answer this question then we know your full of it, know what I'm saying.
    26th Nov 2018

    Please mind your manners 1984
    Karl Marx
    26th Nov 2018
    Thank you Lothario, As far as manners go I will try next time but being the feral I am, well.

    Join YOURLifeChoices, it’s free

    • Receive our daily enewsletter
    • Enter competitions
    • Comment on articles