Flicking the switch from saving to spending is tough for many

Font Size:

When you no longer have a job topping up your bank account regularly, working out your spending in retirement is quite a challenge. It’s a big mind shift that many people struggle with.

A friend of mine, consultant Stephen Huppert, compares the switch from saving for retirement to drawing down savings for spending in retirement as like a cyclist’s switch from riding up the hill to riding down it. The downhill is more unknown, uncertain and risky. It requires a change in thinking, lest you go over the edge.

In the Tour de France, riders often get up to speeds of 110kph on the downhill sections. Terrible accidents sometimes occur, as in 2017 when Australian Richie Porte lost control at 120kph and fractured a collarbone and a hip.

Now, retirement shouldn’t be that scary! You’re looking for peace of mind, not thrills. Still, it does require a change in thinking.

The change is hard for a number of reasons.

First, you’ve spent maybe the past 30 or 40 years saving for retirement, watching that nest egg grow. That felt good, to see the progress you’ve made. You’ve just been able to leave it there and let good markets, compound earnings and your contributions make it bigger. It’s become a pile, most likely larger than you’ve ever had before.

But now, you’ve got to switch to using the pile to fund your retirement living. You’re going to have to draw it down to get yourself what you might call a ‘retirement salary’. The pile’s probably going to shrink … well, that doesn’t feel so good – does it, Uncle Scrooge?

Second, you’ve got to work out just how much you can afford to take from the pile. That’s not easy because you want to have enough money to live comfortably and you want it to last your lifetime. And you don’t know how long you (and your partner) are going to live or what investment returns you’ll earn. Who knows what the financial markets will do in the years ahead?

Third, you’re also probably looking for some help from the government’s Age Pension, either now or in the future. How do you factor that in?

How much you can spend in retirement is actually very complicated. It’s like the problem of how much water a farmer should use to irrigate his crops and still last the long hot summer. It’s the type of problem actuaries get paid big money for solving. But you don’t have an actuary in the family, do you?

How to be a good downhill rider
There are a number of things you can do to find peace of mind in the drawdown phase.

First, make the mind shift. You’re not Scrooge and the point isn’t to die with a big pile of money.

We often see that type of behaviour in real life. Australian Bureau of Statistics figures show that savings for retirees typically rise as they get older and many die with large sums, leaving the money to heirs. They’re underspending compared to what they can afford. It’s most likely due to the natural human fear of running out. Result: we underspend.

As my co-director at Retirement Essentials, Professor Deborah Ralston, says: “People often overestimate the potential costs of health and aged care in their later years. But there’s a lot of government assistance for that. And so many people reduce their spending below a comfortable level as a precautionary measure.”

Second, get your Centrelink entitlements in place as soon as you’re eligible and look to make the most of them. The Age Pension is a fabulous asset for senior Australians. The maximum Age Pension is now $37,000 per annum for a couple and $24,500 for a single. It’s reviewed semi-annually, based on the cost of living and, until this September, increased in each of the past 70 years. And it lasts a lifetime. You can check your Age Pension eligibility here.

Even someone who’s not eligible now for the Age Pension – maybe due to having too much in assets – may well become eligible later in life as savings are spent down. So, it’s a great safety net – effectively meaning that the floor on your retirement income is the maximum Age Pension.

Third, understand your planning horizon. We Australians are living longer than we think. The average man’s life expectancy at age 65 is 85 and the average woman’s is 87. However, that means that about half the people will live longer than that. So, unless you’re not healthy, planning to live into your 90s is probably a safer bet than planning on your 80s. For example, for a couple both currently aged 65, there’s a 24 per cent chance that one person will still be alive at age 95.

And recognise you could live to be 100 or more.

The chart below shows a case study illustrating the impact of long living on what you can afford to spend. It’s for a couple, both aged 66, who have $500,000 between them in financial assets. The longer they are expecting to live, the less they can afford to spend each year. If they were only going to live until 75 – or were prepared to live entirely on the Age Pension after that – Retirement Essentials estimates they could spend $81,900 per year. But if they were planning for a horizon of 90, then $56,400 per year would be a more reasonable expectation. And if planning for 100, then $51,800 would be suitable.

Fourth, work out how much you need and how much you’d like to spend. Everyone has basic needs – we call that your ‘required spending’. And everyone has some extras they’d like, whether including travel or entertainment or gifts for the grandkids. We call the total of ‘required spending’ and the extras ‘desired spending’.

It may well turn out, too, that you’ll want to spend more in your earlier years of retirement and less as you get older. That’s the general pattern in Australia. Average spending tends to decline as people get older. Each quarterly edition of YourLifeChoices’ Retirement Affordability Index tracks changes in the estimated cost of living for three cohorts – the affluents, constrained and cash-strapped retirees – through a formula developed by The Australia Institute. Australian Super Funds Association also publishes its ‘modest’ and ‘comfortable’ living standards.

Keeping control of your budget is a key task for retirees. It’s tough to go out and make up gaps with a part-time job as you get older, so keep good tabs on what you are spending.

And don’t forget to plan for unexpected and lumpy costs – such as a major repair on the house or a new car at some point. It’s always good to keep six months or more of emergency funding available, in case you need it.

One other thing, if you’re retired (over 60) and still in an accumulation super account, you should consider the advantages of an account-based pension. Many people let inertia carry them along and just stick with the regular super account, which is taxed at up to 15 per cent on investment earnings.

At Retirement Essentials, we find almost 30 per cent of our Age Pension clients are still in accumulation super, whereas earnings on an account-based pension, which is designed for the drawdown phase, are tax free – leaving more in your pocket.

It takes a bit of effort to make the move, but it’s usually worthwhile.

Summing up
You can see there’s quite a bit to this drawdown phase. With a bit of careful planning – and maybe some professional help from a financial adviser – it can be a safe and enjoyable ride on an easy downslope.

Were you able to ‘flick the switch’ from saving to spending? Or do you think you’ll be able to do that easily when the time comes? Is there enough support to make this transition?

Jeremy Duffield is a senior executivein the Australian and international financial services sectors. He is the chairman of Retirement Essentials, which assists people to apply for the Age Pension, and of SuperEd, which is focused on helping super fund members plan for their retirement.

If you enjoy our content, don’t keep it to yourself. Share our free eNews with your friends and encourage them to sign up.

Disclaimer: All content in the Retirement Affordability Indexâ„¢ is of a general nature and has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. It has been prepared with due care but no guarantees are provided for the ongoing accuracy or relevance. Before making a decision based on this information, you should consider its appropriateness in regard to your own circumstances. You should seek professional advice from a financial planner, lawyer or tax agent in relation to any aspects that affect your financial and legal circumstances.

Join YourLifeChoices today
and get this free eBook!

By joining YourLifeChoices you consent that you have read and agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy


Our complex system makes independent advice critical

Complex system is setting people up to fail, writes Xavier O'Halloran.

A long life is a wonderful thing – if you’ve planned for it

When you press the retirement button, a sound financial plan is pivotal.

Cost-of-living statistics are valuable; the ‘noise’ is not

Senior economist Matt Grudnoff offers a cautionary tale about statistics.

Written by Jeremy Duffield


Total Comments: 5
  1. 2

    $51,800 a year to live on IF you live to 100!
    H*ll, this is way more than I was getting a year when I WAS working full time. While I do have super it is about a 5th of the $500,000 stated in this story and that is AFTER the extra being added, by myself, to super.
    This mob seem to think that people are able to add extra to super while living on hot air. I’m sorry to tell them that’s NOT THE CASE especially if you’re the only one working in the family!!!!

    • 1

      I agree with you. And once fully retired, and on the Aged Pension, you can no longer contribute to your super. PLUS you are forced to take money out of super. Can’t add, but are forced to reduce what little super you do have. Quite simply, the longer you live, the more you are penalised.

  2. 1

    Jaycee, there are some good tips here. In your case, you have a guaranteed indexed income for life in the aged pension plus the benefits that come with it plus the satisfaction of knowing that your contributions to Super allow you to cover unexpected events because you have a nest egg.

  3. 3

    Some good advice especially the recommendation to use a financial adviser. I know some have been burned using one but we found a good one who set us on the road to a happy retirement. I believe that the need to budget is essential and if there happens to be a bit more in the bank account now and then, go out and splurge to celebrate. I note the reference to the natural human fear of running out and it is this that jeeps people from spending more than wanting to leave it for the children.

  4. 0

    So first up you tell us we’re not spending the retirement super/money quick enough & leaving an inheritance/nest egg & the next breath your’re telling us how it’s not going to go far at all (& needs careful planning to make it last), which I believe to be more likely the case!! There are always going to be normal high cost of living regular expenses & on top of that unexpected expenses (car & household furniture break downs, health costs etc). I’m 59 & currently working & earning a decent wage, but it goes nowhere (a recent car break down cost me $9,500 which I had finally managed to save up for the first time EVER to buy new much needed aluminium windows for my home, but now cannot do because had to fix the bloody car). I do not have further savings or any other money apart from the mediochre super (which I cannot touch til I quit work/retire) so I figure none of these sort of things just magically go away when I retire. So how the heck does this bloke think we are going to die with money in the bank/super account etc?? Some of the articles here at YLC make me think some people are not living in the real world LOL LOL



continue reading

Age Pension

Important details on how your income stream information is updated

Updating Income Stream InformationHi everyone, I wanted to chat about income stream reviews and how they may affect your Age...


Spinach and Parmesan Crustless Quiche

In The Midlife Method, food and lifestyle writer Sam Rice explores why it is so much harder to lose weight...


Jenny Eclair: 'Middle-aged women aren't invisible, they are just ignor

"I've had a lapse back into the menopause today," Jenny Eclair declares at the start of our interview. "I had...

Aged Care

Is your loved one in aged care during the pandemic? Here are seven ideas to make things easier if lockdown strikes again

Many families have faced the stress of having a loved one in aged care during this anxious time of COVID-19....

Health & Ageing

How The Midlife Method author keeps her health on track

In The Midlife Method, food and lifestyle writer Sam Rice explores why it is so much harder to lose weight...


How to … tell if you're oversleeping and what to do

An adult needs between seven-and-a-half to nine hours of sleep each night. If you're consistently sleeping for longer than this...


Hand in hand at London Zoo with a simian friend

YourLifeChoices' 91-year-old columnist Peter Leith recalls an encounter of the simian kind during a visit to London Zoo back in...


Retirement Made Simple

In this interview with podcast host John Deeks, the 80-year-old offers pearls of wisdom on all matters retirement: the sea...