We all wave our supermarket loyalty cards through the machine when we shop and don’t think too much about it.
But there is an increasing trend in supermarkets to offer ‘member’ prices that add another discount, and it’s making us nervous and a little bit cranky.
Consumer advocacy group CHOICE has found four in five Australians think it’s unfair supermarkets charge higher prices for customers who don’t sign up for loyalty programs.
It comes from missing out on specials, but it’s also motivated by shoppers not wanting to hand over personal data to a large corporation to be ‘rewarded’ by cheaper prices.
Because, let’s face it, after Telstra, Optus and Medibank’s data breaches in the past few years, big companies have shown they don’t always have our best interests at heart when it comes to cyber security.
CHOICE surveyed 8000 Australians and found nearly half of them were worried about data being collected about them through loyalty programs.
Doesn’t pay to be loyal
“The Coles and Woolworths duopoly are quick to tout the benefits of their loyalty programs, but we’ve found it doesn’t always pay to be loyal,” says CHOICE senior campaigns and policy advisor Rafi Alam.
“Member-only pricing discriminates against consumers who don’t wish to share their data by signing up. People shouldn’t need to sign up for a loyalty program just to get discounts on products, especially everyday essentials.
“Our survey found 79 per cent of respondents think it’s unfair for supermarkets to charge people more for certain grocery items if they don’t sign up to a loyalty program.
“To make matters worse, Coles and Woolworths collect excessive amounts of personal data through their loyalty programs, and it doesn’t just stay within the scheme.
“Your data may get shared across insurance, credit cards, phone plans or subsidiary businesses. Sadly, there isn’t much transparency on how your data can be used if you sign up,” says Dr Alam.
Woolworths’ Everyday Rewards program allows customers to collect points through its supermarkets, BWS liquor stores and Caltex Woolworth fuel stations. These can be linked to Qantas reward points.
Extra points and perks
It also runs a program called Everyday Extra where customers pay a fee for extra discounts and points and perks.
Coles offers the Flybuys program, which also earns points at Officeworks, Kmart, Target, Liquorland and Bunnings.
It also offers a subscription loyalty program called Coles Plus, with extra points at Coles, 10 times the points at First Choice Liquor and Liquorland, random perks and some discounts on Click and Collect services.
Flybuys can be connected to Velocity Flyer, Virgin’s loyalty program.
In CHOICE’s submission to the recent senate inquiry into supermarket price gouging, the group said loyalty programs were misleading and deceptive.
“Member-only pricing is an unfair pricing practice, as it pushes consumers to sign up to rewards programs – providing their personal information and detailed purchasing behaviour in exchange for cheaper products,” its submission said.
“This is particularly inappropriate when applied to essential products like groceries, as everyone should be able to access affordable groceries without joining a membership program.”
Data breaches
And it’s not like Australia’s supermarket giants haven’t already experienced data breaches.
In 2022, Woolworths had to admit that about 2.2 million customers were hit by a data breach from its MyDeal loyalty program.
The details exposed included customer names, email addresses, phone numbers and delivery addresses, as well as birth dates for people who had to verify their ages when buying alcohol.
And in 2023, Coles announced historical customer credit card details were stolen as part of a breach of the Latitude Financial Services hack.
Are you a member of a subscription supermarket loyalty program? Do you think it’s worth it? Why not share your experience in the comments section below?
Also read: Report recommends forced sale for badly behaved supermarkets
I am a Member of both the Coles and Woolies rewards and pay the subscription fee for the extra benefits on top of the normal rewards.
I also use Woolies mobile which gets me 10% off one shop a month and I make sure I claim it on a big shop which effectively makes the phone free.
I like getting multiple points for anything I buy at the other outlets like Bunnings, K Mart, Big W and Liquorland. Also their online market places which usually has some great bargains and free delivery.
I calculate that I save many times the cost of my subscription annually.
In fact it’s possible to cover the entire annual subs in a month of shopping across all the outlets and it’s all savings after that.
As to the member only supermarket specials, they are both hard to find and usually not good value IMO.
I have Flybuys and use the card at every opportunity. I save the points and use them to buy $50 gift cards for the older grandchildren at Christmas. Any points left over get spent on the Christmas shop.
I have been a Woolworths Rewards member for a long time and use the points to get Qantas FF points, which I have used many times to upgrade flights, or purchase stuff from the Qantas store when they have big sales. I recently joined they Everyday Extra program and for half price ($35 for the first year and then $70 after that). First month free to try, so effectively $35 for 13 months! This gives you 10% off once a month. I re-couped more than that in my first two big shops. I do recommend the program. Also there are free stuff for Rewards Members to try new products. As well, when you join the program, you also get 1 x Big W shop with 10% off per month.