What do you think of Golden Gaytime ice-cream in a tub?

You might already have heard but if not, due to a Facebook campaign called the Golden Gaytime Ice Cream Tub Project by Jesse James McElroy, a Sydney advertising executive, Streets has started selling the beloved Golden Gaytime ice cream in 1.5L tubs.

Golden Gaytimes has been one of Australia's most popular ice creams since it's introduction in 1959, and public opinion is divided over whether this is a good or bad idea. So I've put together a pro/con list. 

Pro:

- More convenient. If you're a big lover of the Golden Gaytime, you won't have to nip into the nearest servo for your fix – the tub will be right there in your freezer.

- It's cheaper. A Golden gaytime from 7/11 costs about $3.70 but a 1.5L tub from the supermarket will cost around $6.99. That's a saving of approximately $1.44 per 100ml. 

- Sharing is caring. You won't have to worry about that family member who insists on taking the last delicious bite of your ice-cream. You can direct them to the tub themselves.


Con:

- Will the tub version be as good as the original? As Jesse James McElroy said, Streets would “need to make sure the biscuits hold up using ... science or magic”. 

- It's just not the same. There's just something about eating an ice cream from stick that you can't beat, isn't there?


What's your take on the Golden Gaytime news? Have you any pros or cons to add to the list. If you're one of the first to have bought the tub, we'd love to hear your thoughts.

11 comments

Too old fashioned .. I prefer Aldi Cookis and cream or peanut butter ..

Or Maggie Bear .. 

What Agency are you with?

havent tried the gaytimes.  but do like them in the packet,   as singles.    PETE.   have you tried AUDIS    BANANA ICE CREAM,      OR THE CHOC MINT,     the banana one is lovely,     i dont eat bananas as  but this ice cream is yummy.   

Quote Amelia: "we'd love to hear your thoughts"

Who is "we"? 

The Ad agency for Gaytime I guess ...

I find ice cream just do not have any flavour except for sweetness.

 I like Mango Weis bars which are made of a moreish combination of Mango and Cream

They are Yum!!!

 

Mango Minis

Almost as good as home made and if you can stop at one or two ... do not cause too much calorie damage :)

 

                                 

I agree the Mango Weis are great

ABBY.    coles put a mango one out,  there own brand.   4 in a packet.   calld MANGOS ONES,    a bit like a gelato,    very nice,     but then as we know,   anything mango is good,         SEE old DENzel is back,    HI DENZEL,      where you been hiding,   ?    been to cold for your naked bod,     lol,     never mind ,    soon be spring,   

The name puts me off

I see this post has the blessing of YLC so it must be a new type of ad from YLC in a advertorial strange to put Ice Cream under hot topics .. 

I suppose the correct response to this childish ad of "What do you think of Gaytime in a tub " is I don't .. But it does sound sexy for our homosexuals element.,

I can't see it having a market in the Eastern Suburbs of Sydney . I think it would only be of interest to the type that buy Coca Cola. 

I see where you are coming from but cannot see any rainbows on the container.

Bit like the Ad for Nobbys Nuts ... Nibble  Nobby's Nuts...

Maybe we could all sing the song .. 

Lets have a gay time 

lets have a gay time 

lets have a gay O time 

Must say that O looks a bit dodgy...

When I have Ice Cream I have plain Vanilla

Guess ice cream is a lot cheaper than Weis bars

I only buy them when they are on special and put them in the freezer.

Because I am on a calorie restricted diet I eat very little ice Cream . So a large Tub would be a waste . I buy from Aldi the smaller Boutique tubs with some fabulous flavours to try. I do like the Weis bars Abbs. 

Comment removed

Stewie, this is a forum about ice cream. If feel you absolutely need to make the type of comments you are making, please direct to this existing forum:

http://www.yourlifechoices.com.au/the_meeting_place/10545

Thank you.

Homo "bashing"?  Not nice!  :-(

And what sort of icecream do you like ?


Image result for ice cream

Never heard of Gaytime ice cream,but eat your hearts out just had my favourite, yum,yum,yum

                              Image result for gelato ice cream in adelaide

Like salted caramel ice cream too..

Have only every tasted one Golden Gaytime Ice-cream in my life, and that was at a cinema in Canberra in 1974, and struggling to remember the name of the film showing at the time of eating said ice cream.  

But to be honest thought it was a tad too sweet, and also to be honest don't much like the idea of the Golden Gaytime Ice-Cream in a tub at all.....

Don't eat much ice-cream but every now and then don't mind treating myself to a 'Drum Stick', but it must be the ORIGINAL vanilla 'Drum Stick' - think I've seen Drum Stick  variations along the line of double choc or something some where...

Nope it must be the original...

Comment removed

Davey, this is a forum about ice cream. If feel you absolutely need to make the type of comments you are making, please direct to this existing forum:

http://www.yourlifechoices.com.au/the_meeting_place/10545

Thank you.

Comment removed

Stewie, it's a forum about ice cream. If feel you absolutely need to make the type of comments you are making, please direct to this existing forum:

http://www.yourlifechoices.com.au/the_meeting_place/10545

Thank you.

11 comments



To make a comment, please register or login

Preview your comment