Australian kids falling for fake news

The Conversation recently conducted a survey focusing on the news engagement practices of 1000 young Australians.

The survey of eight to 16-year-olds revealed that around one third of the respondents could not tell the difference between fake news and real news. Another third said they could work it out the distinction and the remaining third weren't quite sure about their ability.

There is evidence though, that as kids get older, they're more likely to be able to differentiate between real and fake news. Around 42 per cent of Australian teens aged 13-16 reported being able to tell the difference, compared with 27 per cent of children aged eight to 12.

As for where they get their news? Well, you may be surprised to learn that it's not primarily from social media. In fact, the most common news source was through family members (42%), then television (39%), teachers (23%), friends (22%), social media (22%), radio (17%) and newspapers (7%).

Over 50 per cent of teens who were more likely to get news from social media did so from Facebook. Whereas, 37 per cent of younger children used YouTube for news. 

The survey shows that young people are conusming news but aren't sufficiently educated to make infomred decsions about the validity of their sources. And, while the results of this may not be immediately obvious, there is cause for concern about the ability of our children to "participate in society as well-informed citizens".

What do you think about this? Are you surprised that kids this age can't tell fake news from real news? 

10 comments

No surprise at all, adults would be just as guilty of believing the news they would like to be true and avoiding that which does not tally with their view of the world.

This is demonstrated by how easy it is to manipulate voters with meaningless three word slogans and paid political advertising disguised as public information releases, that all seem to be released at election time.  They are as predictable as Tax Cuts just before an election cycle or when a P.M senses he/she is in political peril.

You referring to lieing labor obviously exPS

I mostley just refer to government as I have no unwavering alegiance to any political party.  That sort of devotion is for children or simpletons.  Hence the reference to he/she, you really must learn to pay attention.

I am not surprised at all -- you have to search for the real truth -- as the Main stream media tell us what they are told to and we are treated like Mushrooms -- search it out for yourselves --

 

The reason why they want kids to now start school at the age of 3 it gives them more time to brain wash them

So very correct, PlanB. So very correct.

People should search for the truth ... indeed they need to.  

The media are constrained by policies, and not the least the advertisers with them.

Some years ago an American paper did an in-depth study of polution.  However, the story had to be pulled as one of their leading advertisers (and most lucrative) was the primary culprit.

A free-lance journalist stated that he always learned the policy of the paper to which he contributed, otherwise his articles wouldn't be accepted.

Of the TV news channels, only SBS receive "spray" footage -  news footage that hasn't already been edited.

There are so many ways facts can be mis-represented.  Photographs can be cropped so as to "show" a completely different version of situation.   Then there is the trawling of the "morgue" for old photographs ... often the photographs have no factual relevance to the news story.  Again a misrepresentation.

 

What do you think about this? Are you surprised that kids this age can't tell fake news from real news? 

Nope, not surprised at all. Simple reason being most parents and some teachers can't even spot it themselves and are no help to the kids. This is a great shame, because of this lack of support to help children develop critical thinking skills is leading to increasing levels of mental health problems among young people. Many kids are overwhelmed by a barrage of inaccurate information supplied by Google and other media and word of mouth. Many live their lives completely online, connecting to friends via social media rather than in real life, and for a great number “real life” is becoming a really scary place.

Parents, schools and the media need to recognise the damaging effect that inaccurate and sensationalist news is having on young people and more should be done to help them spot fake news. Critical thinking should be taught in schools and at home because many children are leaving school severely lacking in the ability to think for themselves and to sort out the rubbish from the valid stuff.

This is a great topic by the way.


Yup, "my dear", I agree with everything you say and would also point out the dangers of fake news promulgated by some journalists. Some deliberately, others unwittingly. For example the recent headlines about Angela Merkel being mentally ill and Macron being gay. And who can forget the most famous headline of all about Freddie Starr eating a hamster??

You mean to say it’s not true “my dears?” Freddie Starr did not injest said rodent? To think I felt so sorry for these poor rats, I have gone out of my way to provide an enclosure for all cricetidae in my zoo. I have been taken in by false information yet  again!

Isaac, I emphatically agree, if I had been taught at school to distinguish between fake and real news, I would not have been duped :(


It warms the cockles of my heart my friends to see you’ve both learnt something tonight. My work is done – for now.

Off to sample a glass of Penfolds Bin 407 Cabernet Sav. Goodnight “my dears.”

Chaps, you make it worth my while coming in. Enjoy the humour. Isaac, a lot of truth in your post. 

Many first year university students I have found, have not been able to differentiate between fake and real news even at that stage of their education. In my experience, it's been a long road trying to polish their critical thinking skills.

As you point out Isaac, both schools and parents should make a concerted effort to help kids out in this respect.

 

How many times do you tell someone about something and they say

-- if it is NOT on mainstream media it can't be true ---

How come nothing has been told about the likes of what is and has been happening in Japan after the Fukushima disaster -- and how come -- and what money changed hands to allow them to hold the Olympics there in 2020!         Search that out -- and how come there are STILL Sushi bars around selling the Nori   (the seaweed)   from Japan -- which has been contaminated since at least 2011 as well as many other products that are STILL imported and now NOT even checked.

How come they have and still do from time to time have very cheap airfares to Japan -- and at one time had FREE air travel --- because their economy is bad and they need the tourist industry -- search it out for your own good

 

The young people of today know NOTHING about the dangers of radiation and I am sure have never been taught -- even at Uni level

WHY are so many Babies being born with Brain cancer and other dreadful cancers -- because Radiation destroys the DNA and that exhibits mistakes in further generations.

There has also been an escalation in cancers since 1945.

Cancer can take as few as 2 to 5 years to show -- or up to 40 or 50 but it will show but because of the length of time so many do NOT equate it with such things as Radiation exposure.

This is not in the mainstream media -- ( unless it is at 1 am in the morning)    but there is a lot on the net --

 

Unfortunatley the Media is controled by powerful organisation by the way of advertising spending.

We had a Premier in this state who spent hundreds of thousands on advertising, if a paper published a story he did not like, he would threaten to pull his advertising and the story would either dissapear or a follow up differring opinion would be written the following day.

The Madia is controlled by those with money and power.

We must teach our children to choose wisely in the plethora of media available in the modern world . 

I for instance turn to New Idea or the Daily Mail to get the latest news on celebrities or the date of Prince Harry’s wedding. 

Or for the Labor/Green view of the World the ABC is invaluable .

Thats just it Brocky they know more about the    "Celebs"   than whats happen to this planet -- and not only the young ones either I know a Woman of 75 that can tell you all about the film stars but knows not a thing about much else,  I find that very disturbing

From the original post:

As for where they get their news? Well, you may be surprised to learn that it's not primarily from social media. In fact, the most common news source was through family members (42%), then television (39%), teachers (23%), friends (22%), social media (22%), radio (17%) and newspapers (7%).

From the survey (here):

The news topic rated most important by young Australians (ranked 4 or 5) is technology (52%). This was followed by events and issues in their local community (43%) and news about education and schools (39%). News about sport and news about health issues were also ranked well with 36% each. By far, ‘news about politics including what happens in parliament’ received the least number of important ratings (18%).

——————————
Based on the above, guess we need to educate the family members first and make political coverage interesting enough that they even bother to pay attention to it, fake news or not.

When the president of an English teachers’ association, who chairs a government curriculum committee, recently editorialised that his English teachers had failed because generations of former students had re-elected John Howard, he well and truly let the cat out of the bag. 

 

This was that much of our children’s tuition has been requisitioned to promote a left-wing political agenda, even in the teaching of English.

 

This is only part of that same long march by the left-wing intelligentsia, the elites, through so many of the institutions of our nation. This includes much of our elite media, which remain a significant agenda setter for all the other media. 

 

David Marr, the former presenter of ABC TV’s Media Watch has decreed that if journalists do not come from a “soft-leftie kind of culture” they should “get another job”.

 

Accordingly, instead of objectively investigating and reporting on the great issues of the nation, the elite media now serve the public a never ending diet of partisan opinion disguised as facts based comment, often indistinguishable from the news, the items of which are regularly selected to be consistent with their agenda.

 

A corps of campaigning political journalists has descended into the political arena as participants who are both unelected and unaccountable, unashamedly advancing an agenda that is out of touch and alien to the overwhelming majority of Australians. 

 

http://www.onlineopinion.com.au/view.asp?article=3274

 

Shared via the Google app

 

Completely true

Really, so if a teacher or principal mkaes a negative remark aout a Labor politician, it is a government plot against socialism?  I expect better from you Brocky, but when it comes tp politics your eyes seem to be blinkered.

So it must be, but it does hamper your credidibility somewhat.

We obviosly disagree about the long match of the left through our institutions in particular the media and education . 

Their is a difference between a political / economic philosophy and politics which is supposed to be the implementation of a theory . 

It is sadly lacking in Australian politics which has become managerial .

Are you going to tell us what your gobbledygook means? Or do we have to guess?

All media is censored.

The Editors or producers choose as to what to present to us as “News”

In the chase to seek attention we are presented with a never ending list of crisis.

There is an implicit rule of media: if it bleeds it leads.

Good one Twilsy 

It used to be that reporters were there to report the facts, not the facts as they see them.  I do not need some wet behind the ears teenager interpreting the news for me, I like to make my own mistakes.

Lets have more Journalists like John Pilger and his like

Pilger is part of the problem not the solution .

WHY?  do you say that Brocky

Hi Plan B read my post of 22 hrs ago . 

Is this what you were talking about Brocky?  

avatarBrocky4 hrs ago

http://www.thecommentator.com/article/4707/john_pilger_and_the_lie

 

Thanks for putting the site up -- and I will be sure an read it right through as soon as I can do so

Ooops sorry about posting your photo too Brocky 

 

Brocky posts his picture and his family's everywhere on the site and then accuses others of doing same. How strange can you get eh ???

10 comments



To make a comment, please register or login

Preview your comment